The insidious silencing of important works of art by women continues. This
time it's the gov't of Ontario, Canada. Please direct protest email to:
Tuesday November 20 5:56 PM EST
Yahoo! News
Appeal panel upholds decision to ban controversial film Fat Girl in Ontario
By ANDREA BAILLIE
TORONTO (CP) - The Ontario Film Review Board's decision to ban a critically
praised movie about the sexual awakening of two sisters was upheld Tuesday
by an appeal panel.
In a 3-2 vote, the five-member panel supported an earlier move to keep Fat
Girl from the province's movie theatres because of sexual nudity involving
teenagers. "The feeling was (the nudity) probably wasn't necessary to get
the point across," said review board chair Robert Warren. <--
robert.warren@cbs.gov.on.ca
Fat Girl, directed by France's Catherine Breillat, examines sexual rites of
passage through the eyes of pudgy 13-year-old Anais (Anais Reboux), and her
beautiful 15-year-old sister Elena (Roxane Mesquida).
Titled A Ma Soeur! in French, the film was screened at the Toronto
International Film Festival and has received impressive reviews.
Peter Travers of Rolling Stone hailed Fat Girl as an "absolute stunner,"
adding that "Breillat draws delicately nuanced performances from Mesquida
and Reboux, and creates a raw portrait of female virginity under siege that
has the blunt ring of truth."
In the New York Times, Stephen Holden said the film "is much more than a
perfectly realized vignette about seduction. It is the latest and most
powerful dispatch yet from Ms. Breillat, France's most impassioned
correspondent covering the war between the sexes."
The film, which has been approved by boards in Quebec, British Columbia and
the United Kingdom and has also been released in the United States, was
rejected by two earlier Ontario review board panels.
Under the province's Theatres Act, the board can reject a film if it shows
sex-related nudity involving someone who is underage or appears to be
underage.
Co-distributors Cowboy Pictures and Lion's Gate films have refused to cut
the offending scenes and launched an appeal that included letters from
directors Atom Egoyan and David Cronenberg as well as academics who argued
the film's merits.
Now that the appeal has been rejected, Warren said the distributors have
three options: to cut the film and re-submit it, to not distribute the film
in Ontario, or to contest the decision in court.
Cowboy Pictures co-president Noah Cowan said Tuesday from New York that the
company had not yet decided its next move, but reiterated that the film
would not be cut.
Cowan has repeatedly suggested the ban hearkens back to the Ontario film
review board's decisions in the early 1980s to ban acclaimed films like
Louis Malle's Pretty Baby and Volker Schlondorff's The Tin Drum.
"I'm extremely upset. I'm an Ontarian ... I remember not being able to see
the greatest films being made in the rest of the world," said Cowan, former
associate director for the Toronto International Film Festival.
"It seemed like a distant nightmare. And here I am, involved in a situation
where this is all happening again."
Cowan said statements he received from two panel members who voted in favour
of the film suggest the decision doesn't reflect the feeling of the general
population.
"We received .. written statements from two of the board members deploring
the decision," he said.
"(The board has) gone against what I feel is the will of Ontario here. This
is not a decision that reflects the community standards of Ontario. This is
a decision that condescends and insults the people of Ontario."
But Warren insisted the decision to ban the film has sparked more positive
e-mails and phone calls to the review board than negative ones.
"We do an awful lot to try and make sure we're plugged in (to community
standards)," he said. "A lot of people say if it's artistic, it doesn't
matter what's in it. (But) film classification boards are in the business of
drawing boundaries."
He did acknowledge, however, that the board's decision is a highly unusual
one.
"When we're talking mainstream (movies) it's pretty unprecedented," he said.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Wed Nov 21 2001 - 18:08:15 CET