RE: hip hop

From: Philip Sherburne (psherburne@jeevessolutions.com)
Date: Tue Jul 10 2001 - 00:41:17 CEST

  • Next message: Marco: "RE: In My CD Changer"

    > let the academics and the media try to define, the music
    > producers, true
    > listeners, and DJs should simply say that about all music
    >
    > there is only good and bad

    i'm sorry, but i've heard this comment, or comments like it, too many times
    in the past week, and i have to respond. to be blunt, i think it's fucking
    idiotic. why do people seem so afraid of analyzing, categorizing, and
    differentiating music? "defining" music, eg genres, formal criteria, etc.,
    does NOT have to be a negative thing. indeed, there's a reason this is the
    "acid-jazz" list, not the "good music" (or "bad music," depending on your
    perspective) list.

    if there were only good and bad music, there wouldn't be much use talking
    about it, would there?

    not trying to be a dick here... i just think this anxiety is a bit off the
    mark. "definition" (which i would include as a part of any broader analysis)
    something we all do, not just "academics and the media."

    cheers
    philip



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Tue Jul 10 2001 - 01:16:33 CEST